Getting Away with Murder – How Politics is Destroying the Criminal Justice System - Hardcover

Reading this book is like being...at a dinner party with a scintillating legal expert overflowing with enthusiasm and insights into virtually every topic within her field of expertise. From the trials of O.J. Simpson and the Menendez brothers to the insanity defense, battered wives syndrome, and Willie Horton... Estrich renders one clever, thought-provoking opinion after another--each connected to her personal philosophy of law...Focussing particularly on the criminal law process, "Getting Away with Murder" describes a system that has become a forum for indulging our deepest social divisions--'a lowest common denominator search for false equality'--rather than a place for restoring the ties of trust and good faith that ought to bind up our ever more diverse society...These days, the emperor of law may have been reduced to his undergarments. But the nation will be well served following Estrich's attempt to reclothe him in all the finery we can muster. -- Edward Lazarus "L.A. Times" In Getting Away With Murder Estrich wants to save our troubled criminal justice system from various threats, including a pervasive tendency to employ 'abuse excuses' to defend people who commit crimes of extreme violence. She believes we are agents of free will, in spite of our genes and personal circumstances. In her view, we must hold one another accountable for our choices if we are to have a functioning society...[She] explores all sides of an issue, even raising prospective rebuttals and facing mitigating arguments head on...[Her book] is, at bottom, persuasive: We must have a unified vision of our justice system if it is to serve us as a society. Don't be fooled by the subtitle of this smart and lively book: Susan Estrich is not against politics in our criminal justice system, but for it. Indeed, she thinks some sort of politics is inevitable, so the key question about, say, criminal juries is not "whether" they should do politics, but "how." What is destroying the system, Estrich says, is a 'separatist, ' 'balkanized' and 'dishonest' politics. In its place, she summons up a vision of a unifying politics, focusing not on what tears Americans apart but on what brings us together...She delivers an impressive product--a broad critique of the current system and a road map for reform built on faith in the common sense of common people.--Akhil Reed Amar "New York Times Book Review " In this short, lively and spirited book, Ms. Estrich tries to reestablish for the average reader the enormous importance that the law attaches to the 'reasonable person.' It is by the standards of that person that we judge the motives of criminals and the circumstances they confront...If you wish a stimulating introduction to this problem [of corruption in the U.S. legal system], her book is a good place to start.--James Q. Wilson "Washington Times " Ms. Estrich has set herself the complex task of dismantling US attitudes with rather more effective tools than the prevailing prejudices. In this lively, well-debated book, she fires continuous questions at the reader like bullets...Ms Estrich's key point is that under US law everybody is supposed to be treated the same but the way in which the same is interpreted is steeped in political connotations...She illustrates her arguments with an array of extraordinary cases that demonstrate just how much the US and British criminal justice systems are prey to the questions of where to set boundaries--and the issue of who should set them.--Rachel Halliburton "The Gazette " [Reading this book] is like being...at a dinner party [with a] scintillating legal expert overflowing with enthusiasm and insights into virtually every topic within [her] field of expertise. From the trials of O.J. Simpson and the Menendez brothers to the insanity defense, battered wives syndrome, [and] Willie Horton...[Estrich] renders one clever, thought-provoking opinion after another--each connected to [her] personal philosophy of law...Focussing particularly on the criminal law process, "Getting Away with Murder" describes a system that has become a forum for indulging our deepest social divisions--'a lowest common denominator search for false equality'--rather than a place for restoring the ties of trust and good faith that ought to bind up our ever more diverse society...These days, the emperor of law may have been reduced to his undergarments. But the nation will be [well] served following Estrich's attempt to reclothe him in all the finery we can muster.--Edward Lazarus "L.A. The scope of the topic is wide, encompassing equality in criminal punishment, racism in the jury system, legislative reactions to crime and legal ethics in representing accused criminals...The brevity of author Estrich's work is due to her mental nimbleness. She scurries through her field of ideas and inspects facts like found objects, turning them around to see them from all angles. She wants her readers to be explorers too, so she hypothetically changes facts by degrees, keeping our minds limber. No doubt, this is a style she has honed as a professor of criminal law at [the University of Southern California].--Eve Lichtgarn "California Journal of Law " In "Getting Away With Murder" Estrich wants to save our troubled criminal justice system from various threats, including a pervasive tendency to employ 'abuse excuses' to defend people who commit crimes of extreme violence. She believes we are agents of free will, in spite of our genes and personal circumstances. In her view, we must hold one another accountable for our choices if we are to have a functioning society...[She] explores all sides of an issue, even raising prospective rebuttals and facing mitigating arguments head on...[Her book] is, at bottom, persuasive: We must have a unified vision of our justice system if it is to serve us as a society.--Beret E. Strong "California Lawyer " Estrich writes with fire and passion, and it can jump right off the page and instill these emotions in the reader...In clear, concise language the author graphically describes the destructive influence of politics on the system. This book would be very suitable for students in criminal justice, political science, public policy, or law. It will challenge the reader's assumptions on every page.--Edward Tromanhauser "Criminal Justice Review "

Susan Estrich is Robert Kingsley Professor of Law and Political Science at the University of Southern California.